Jean Nouvel’s New York Tower: A Question of Structure

A recent NYTimes story by Nicolai Ouroussoff discusses the appearance of a dramatic new tower design on the skyline of New York City. The new 75-story tower, designed by world renowned architect Jean Nouvel for the developer Hines, will house an extension of MoMA (adjacent to the site), a hotel, and luxury condominiums. The [...]

By jonasrisen

Posts by jonasrisen
jonasrisen’s Website

Nouvel_Hines_Image 01

A recent NYTimes story by Nicolai Ouroussoff discusses the appearance of a dramatic new tower design on the skyline of New York City. The new 75-story tower, designed by world renowned architect Jean Nouvel for the developer Hines, will house an extension of MoMA (adjacent to the site), a hotel, and luxury condominiums. The article discusses at length the reasons behind the project in the context of a relatively conservative period in New York high-rise tower design.

The author asks:

How did a profit-driven developer become more adventurous architecturally than MoMA, which has tended to make cautious choices in recent years?

and then answers:

Hines [who MoMA sold the site to] asked Mr. Nouvel to come up with two possible designs for the site. A decade ago anyone who was about to invest hundreds of millions on a building would inevitably have chosen the more conservative of the two. But times have changed. Architecture is a form of marketing now, and Hines made the bolder choice.

Nouvel_Hines_Image 02 What I find truly fascinating about this structure is the dynamic structural system exposed on the facade. Subtly stated at the bottom of the article hidden behind speculation of motivations of the developer and poor decisions by MoMA is the real gem, that the structural system was chosen based on requirements by zoning, sight lines, and foundation pressures. The building quite literally contorts itself into the proposed shape as a means of fulfilling a number of city regulations and program requirements. In one gesture the building peels back to expose views for the residential museum tower. In another move, the building is cut away on the northeast corner to conform to zoning regulations.

Nouvel_Hines_Image 03 Also, using large structural members on the facade, in the crisscrossed pattern shown above, the architect was able to create expansive floor plates which are relatively free of columns. It is a rather trendy move to use the exposed “wireframe” structural system, but maybe the justification for such a system is genuine in some cases. I question whether a building could be so nimble in meeting it’s constraints if there was no such structural technology. No word yet on whether the building systems will have any intelligent attributes as it appears the structural system has adopted. I for one hope that the designers realize their responsibility to deliver a high performance building trumps ego or simple aesthetics.

For more information read the original article in the New York Times.

Tags: , , ,
Post a comment or leave a trackback: Trackback URL.

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked *

*
*

  • News

  • <?php the_title(); ?>
  • 08.Dec
  • 15 Greenest Cities on the Globe

  • I am oftentimes skeptical about the myriad of lists one can find out there covering everything from foreclosure rates in metro areas to best cities to fall in love. I have a hard time with most of these rankings because I am a big fan of quantifying results before something is published as truth and [...]

  • Products

  • <?php the_title(); ?>
  • 22.Oct
  • Counterfeit Countertops

  • All Paper Recycling, Inc. has created a product called Shetka Stone that can be used for a variety of uses including countertops, fabricated panels, benches and tile. Shetkastone is made from100% pre and post consumer waste paper, including counterfeit money and phone books. The material is scratch, stain, and water resistant and [...]

  • Case Studies

  • <?php the_title(); ?>
  • 23.Jun
  • Kelvin’s Conjecture: The Sustainability of Optimization and Integration

  • ”to make as effective, perfect, or useful as possible“ -Definition ‘Optimize’
    The National Aquatic Center in Beijing achieves sustainability through the optimization and integration of its structure, envelope, and building systems. In doing so it tells the story of how a little known problem of theoretical physics, Kelvin’s Conjecture, influenced the design of a prominent international [...]

  • Environment

  • <?php the_title(); ?>
  • 24.Oct
  • Phytoremediation-a safe alternative?

  • Recently I had the benefit of sitting in on lecture about using plants to treat environmental problems. The lecture was given by Dr. Lee A. Newman, who has been conducting research in the area of phytoremediation for the past 16 years. Her work at the University of South Carolina focuses on using plants [...]

  • Events News

  • <?php the_title(); ?>
  • 17.Oct
  • Climate Change Exhibit

  • An exhibit on the effects of Climate Change opens tommorow at the Museum of Natural History in New York and runs through August 16, 2009.
    “Climate Change will use realistic dioramas, hands-on activity stations, and dynamic animations to understand the climate’s response to the build-up of greenhouse gases and explore the repercussions for today’s world and [...]

About Greenline

Greenline is an open forum run by the GreenTeam at Ziger/Snead LLP Architects.

Our mission is to collect and share news and information on building technology, strategies, and products both within our office and with consultants, clients and future building occupants. We believe that education is fundamental to good design work, and so we have designed this blog as a resource to learn, explore and share topics such as high performance building, sustainable design, innovative products, health and productivity in buildings, and design aesthetics.

Save or Share